1. Best overall — SKIMS
★ Editor's top pick
SKIMS
Fits Everybody collection · USA
4.4/5
★★★★★
SKIMS' Fits Everybody line is genuinely one of the best everyday underwear products on the market right now. The fabric has an almost liquid softness to it — it moves with the body, doesn't dig in, and stays invisible under tight clothing. The brand's commitment to extended sizing (XXS–5X) makes it accessible to a far wider range of bodies than most competitors.
Pros
- Exceptionally soft fabric
- Wide size range (XXS–5X)
- Seamless and invisible under clothes
- Flattering on most body types
Cons
- Sells out quickly
- Mid-range pricing
2. Best lace — Hanky Panky
Hanky Panky
Original Rise Thong · USA
4.3/5
★★★★☆
Hanky Panky's stretch lace thong has been a wardrobe staple since 1977 for a reason: it's comfortable in a way that lace has no right to be. The four-way stretch means it fits a range of sizes without feeling constrictive. It's the rare piece of lingerie that women genuinely wear every day rather than saving for special occasions.
Pros
- Iconic, truly comfortable lace
- Four-way stretch fits many sizes
- Holds shape wash after wash
- Classic aesthetic
Cons
- Limited extended sizing
- One signature style
3. Most inclusive — TomboyX
TomboyX
Boxer Brief & Core collection · USA
4.5/5
★★★★★
TomboyX built a brand around a simple idea: underwear shouldn't be gendered, and it should fit every body. Their boxer brief for women and gender-expansive individuals is the best in class — pima cotton, full coverage, no wedgies, and a thoughtful elastic waistband. The size range runs XS–6X and the fit is consistently praised across body types.
Pros
- Genuinely size-inclusive (XS–6X)
- Gender-expansive sizing model
- Soft pima cotton fabric
- Full coverage options
Cons
- Slightly higher price point
- Fewer feminine silhouettes
Sizing note: TomboyX uses a gender-neutral sizing model. Their fit guide on-site is excellent — use it rather than guessing from your usual women's size.
4. Best fashion pick — Adore Me
Adore Me
Lingerie & everyday collections · USA
4.2/5
★★★★☆
Adore Me is the brand that proves you don't need to spend a fortune on beautiful lingerie. Their rotating collections bring runway-inspired designs at accessible prices, with a VIP membership model that drops the per-set cost significantly. The size range extends to 46DDD/3XL — better than most fashion lingerie brands.
Pros
- Fashion-forward designs
- Accessible price point
- Wide size range available
- VIP membership savings
Cons
- VIP model requires management
- Quality varies by style
5. Best sustainable — Organic Basics
Organic Basics
GOTS organic cotton · Denmark
4.3/5
★★★★☆
Organic Basics wins on credentials: GOTS-certified organic cotton, OEKO-TEX Standard 100, and a fully transparent supply chain. The Danish minimalism shows in the design — clean cuts, neutral tones, nothing unnecessary. If you're conscious about what touches your skin and what your purchases support, this is the brand.
Pros
- GOTS & OEKO-TEX certified
- Skin-safe, no harsh chemicals
- Clean minimal aesthetic
- Transparent manufacturing
Cons
- Premium price
- Limited color/print options
6. Best value — Calvin Klein
Calvin Klein
Modern Cotton & Ideal Cotton · USA
4.2/5
★★★★☆
Calvin Klein's Modern Cotton collection is the reliable workhorse of women's underwear. The iconic logo waistband, consistent sizing, and widely available price points (especially on sale at department stores) make it the brand most women have at least a few pairs of. The cotton-modal blend is softer than pure cotton and holds up well over time.
Pros
- Widely available & on sale often
- Consistent sizing across styles
- Cotton-modal blend is comfortable
- Classic, timeless aesthetic
Cons
- Nothing innovative
- Branding not for everyone
Full comparison table
| Brand | Rating | Price/pair | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|
| SKIMS Top pick | ★★★★★ 4.4 | $18–$60 | Everyday softness |
| TomboyX | ★★★★★ 4.5 | $20–$38 | Inclusive sizing |
| Hanky Panky | ★★★★☆ 4.3 | $24–$42 | Lace & special occasions |
| Organic Basics | ★★★★☆ 4.3 | $28–$52 | Sustainability |
| Adore Me | ★★★★☆ 4.2 | $12–$32 | Fashion on a budget |
| Calvin Klein | ★★★★☆ 4.2 | $18–$45 | Reliable everyday value |
Buying guide: what to look for
Fabric for your lifestyle
Modal and micro-modal are the softest options — ideal for everyday wear. Cotton is breathable and best for sensitive skin. Nylon/spandex blends are best for athletic use and seamless layering. Lace is beautiful but choose stretch lace (like Hanky Panky) for comfort.
Getting the right cut
- Briefs: Full coverage, great for everyday. Look for tagless options.
- Hipster: Lower rise, good coverage, works under most pants.
- Thong: Invisible under tight clothes. Stretch lace (Hanky Panky) or soft modal for comfort.
- Boxer brief: Growing in popularity. TomboyX makes the best. Great for thigh chafe and full coverage.
Sizing and fit
Women's underwear sizing is less standardized than men's. Always check the brand's own size guide — especially for brands like TomboyX or SKIMS that use extended or gender-neutral sizing models. When in doubt, size up: underwear that's slightly loose is far more comfortable than underwear that's too tight.
Shopping tip: SKIMS and Adore Me both have frequent restocks and sales. Follow them on email or social media — SKIMS in particular sells out fast on new colorways.